11,143
edits
Are Christians required to tithe?: Difference between revisions
→Jacob's tithing was conditional
| Line 286: | Line 286: | ||
#Abraham also was '''required to be circumcised''' as part of the covenant, does that mean that circumcision is also required today? | #Abraham also was '''required to be circumcised''' as part of the covenant, does that mean that circumcision is also required today? | ||
Gen 14:20 provides no evidence that Abraham continuously or regularly tithed. Abraham was never commanded to give a tenth on a regular basis, and there is no evidence that Abraham ever tithed again. His giving of a tithe to Melchizedek should therefore be considered a voluntary gift for the priestly functions performed by Melchizedek and a thank offering given to God for military victory. The context of Gen 14:20–24 seems to assume that Abram had the right to keep the spoils for himself. Indeed, if | Gen 14:20 provides no evidence that Abraham continuously or regularly tithed. Abraham was never commanded to give a tenth on a regular basis, and there is no evidence that Abraham ever tithed again. His giving of a tithe to Melchizedek should therefore be considered a voluntary gift for the priestly functions performed by Melchizedek and a thank offering given to God for military victory. The context of Gen 14:20–24 seems to assume that Abram had the right to keep the spoils for himself. Indeed, '''if Abraham’s tithing is any kind of model for Christians, it provides support only for occasional tithes of unusual sources of income.''' | ||
===Jacob's tithing was conditional=== | ===Jacob's tithing was conditional=== | ||
| Line 292: | Line 292: | ||
In Gen 28:22, Jacob promised to give God a tithe: | In Gen 28:22, Jacob promised to give God a tithe: | ||
:''Then Jacob made a vow to the LORD: | :''Then Jacob made a vow to the LORD: “'''If''' you will be with me and protect me on the journey I am making and give me food and clothing, and if I return safely to my father’s home, then you will be my God. This memorial stone which I have set up will be the place where you are worshipped, and I will give you a tenth of everything you give me.”<ref>American Bible Society, The Holy Bible: The Good News Translation, 2nd ed. (New York: American Bible Society, 1992), Ge 28:20–22.</ref>'' | ||
Jacob’s vow is very revealing in that it is a conditional vow. “If” God does what he asks, “then” | Jacob’s vow is very revealing in that it is a conditional vow. “If” God does what he asks, “then” Jacob will do certain things. The “conditions” placed upon God in Gen 28:20–22 are as follows: | ||
:(1) if God will stay with Jacob; | :(1) if God will stay with Jacob; | ||
| Line 307: | Line 307: | ||
:(3) he will give a tenth of all that God gives him. | :(3) he will give a tenth of all that God gives him. | ||
While narratives in the OT can serve as examples of faith for all believers (see Heb 11), this is not one of those examples. Interpreters need to read these narratives critically; not every | '''While narratives in the OT can serve as examples of faith for all believers (see Heb 11), this is not one of those examples'''. Interpreters need to read these narratives critically; not every passage presents the patriarchs or kings positively. Gen 28:22 should not be read as suggesting that Christians ought to emulate Jacob’s behavior. Rather, it teaches believers to avoid spiritual immaturity or unbelief. Jacob seems to be trying to bribe God and buy God’s blessing. Jacob also seems to have been a specialist in the area of negotiation (see Gen 25:29–34; 29:18). In fact, he does not appear to be converted yet as his conversion appears to have taken place when he wrestled with God (Gen 32:24–30), not in his dream in Gen 28. | ||
As with Abraham's example, it appears that the giving of this tithe was voluntary on Jacob's part. There is no evidence in the text to suggest that tithing was the general practice of Jacob's life. If he did in fact begin to tithe after God fulfilled His promises to him, Jacob still delayed tithing for 20 years! What is also important is the question of how he gave this tithe to God. Was it through sacrifice or by giving to the poor? There is no indication that he ever met Melchizedek. | As with Abraham's example, it appears that the giving of this tithe was voluntary on Jacob's part. There is no evidence in the text to suggest that tithing was the general practice of Jacob's life. If he did in fact begin to tithe after God fulfilled His promises to him, Jacob still delayed tithing for 20 years! What is also important is the question of how he gave this tithe to God. Was it through sacrifice or by giving to the poor? There is no indication that he ever met Melchizedek. | ||
| Line 327: | Line 327: | ||
Tithe. In the Mosaic Law, the Levites stood between Israel and God, offering daily sacrifices for sin. Numbers 18:21 and Lev 27:30–33 declare that the Levites will receive the tithe for their services as payment for bearing this burden and for not getting an inheritance of land: | Tithe. In the Mosaic Law, the Levites stood between Israel and God, offering daily sacrifices for sin. Numbers 18:21 and Lev 27:30–33 declare that the Levites will receive the tithe for their services as payment for bearing this burden and for not getting an inheritance of land: | ||
:'' | :''The LORD said, “I have given to the Levites every tithe that the people of Israel present to me. This is in payment for their service in taking care of the Tent of my presence.<ref>American Bible Society, The Holy Bible: The Good News Translation, 2nd ed. (New York: American Bible Society, 1992), Nu 18:21.</ref>'' | ||
:''One-tenth of all the produce of the land, whether grain or fruit, belongs to the LORD. If a man wishes to buy any of it back, he must pay the standard price plus an additional twenty per cent. One out of every ten domestic animals belongs to the LORD. When the animals are counted, every tenth one belongs to the LORD. The owner may not arrange the animals so that the poor animals are chosen, and he may not make any substitutions. If he does substitute one animal for another, then both animals will belong to the LORD and may not be bought back.<ref>American Bible Society, The Holy Bible: The Good News Translation, 2nd ed. (New York: American Bible Society, 1992), Le 27:30–33.</ref> | :''One-tenth of all the produce of the land, whether grain or fruit, belongs to the LORD. If a man wishes to buy any of it back, he must pay the standard price plus an additional twenty per cent. One out of every ten domestic animals belongs to the LORD. When the animals are counted, every tenth one belongs to the LORD. The owner may not arrange the animals so that the poor animals are chosen, and he may not make any substitutions. If he does substitute one animal for another, then both animals will belong to the LORD and may not be bought back.<ref>American Bible Society, The Holy Bible: The Good News Translation, 2nd ed. (New York: American Bible Society, 1992), Le 27:30–33.</ref> | ||