Was the birth of Joseph Branham foretold?: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
No edit summary
Line 22: Line 22:
:''...And I--I believe it's just ahead of me. I-- what I've ask for is, I believe that God has it just ahead. I believe I'll live to see it. And that's what I pray for.''
:''...And I--I believe it's just ahead of me. I-- what I've ask for is, I believe that God has it just ahead. I believe I'll live to see it. And that's what I pray for.''


Is this a clear prophecy, or is it simply a man asking God for something?
=Why did he think Billy Paul was the fulfillment of this prayer?=
Then of Billy Paul, he said:
Then of Billy Paul, he said:


:''My Joseph was right with me when--and I didn't know it.
:''My Joseph was right with me when--and I didn't know it.


Is this a clear prophecy?  '''Or is it simply a man asking God for something?'''  Certainly if Joseph had never been born, we could not have pointed back at this event, as we can with the [[The Brown Bear Vision|vision of the Brown Bear]] or [[The Vision of the Meetings in South Africa|the vision of the meetings in South Africa]] and state that the vision was not fulfilled.  William Branham does not mention a vision at this time.  It is '''only mentioned after the fact'''.
=Vision only mentioned after the fact=


==Vision only mentioned after the fact==
*William Branham does not mention a vision until after Joseph was born. 
*After Joseph is born, he states that he had a vision showing his son's birth. 
*William Branham then claimed it wasn't a vision, but was just something he felt was coming from the Lord. 
*Then he later states that he did have a clear vision that Joseph would be born.


Another issue is that, if you read the quotes below, William Branham never indicated in advance of the birth that he had seen a vision.  Then later, after Joseph is born, he states that he had a vision showing his son's birth.  Then he subsequently states it wasn't a vision but was just something he felt was coming from the Lord.  He then later states that he did have a clear vision that he would have a son and that he was to name him Joseph.  Is that a clear prophecy?
Is this a clear prophecy?


Based on this, the birth of Joseph Branham cannot be considered to have been a clear prophecy given publicly before the fact that was later clearly fulfilled.


=Quotes of William Branham=
=Quotes of William Branham=