A response to Bernard's views on women's hair: Difference between revisions

No edit summary
Line 71: Line 71:
What he never says, anywhere in the passage:
What he never says, anywhere in the passage:


He never says women may not cut or trim their hair. He never sets a minimum length. He never states that any deliberate reduction in a woman's hair length is sinful. He never says this rule applies "regardless of culture," as Bernard asserts. He never frames this as a creation ordinance that transcends cultural variation.
#He never says women may not cut or trim their hair.  
#He never sets a minimum length.  
#He never states that any deliberate reduction in a woman's hair length is sinful.  
#He never says this rule applies "regardless of culture," as Bernard asserts.  
#He never frames this as a creation ordinance that transcends cultural variation.


Bernard's prohibition — "women should not trim it or otherwise seek to shorten it deliberately" — is not in this passage. It cannot be derived from what Paul says without filling in a significant gap with an assumption that Fee's careful exegesis shows the text does not support.
Bernard's prohibition — "women should not trim it or otherwise seek to shorten it deliberately" — is not in this passage. It cannot be derived from what Paul says without filling in a significant gap with an assumption that Fee's careful exegesis shows the text does not support.