BelieveTheSign

Franklin D. Roosevelt: Difference between revisions

← Older edit
VisualWikitext
No edit summary
 
(14 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
__NOTOC__
{{Top of Page}}
{| style="width:800px"
{{1933 Visions}}
William Branham claimed he had a series of eight prophetic visions in June 1933. In the first vision, Franklin D. Roosevelt picked on the Germans and started the Second World War. William Branham stopped telling this part of the prophecy in 1961, but still maintained that there were seven other major parts to the 1933 vision that were "Thus Saith The Lord".
= Franklin D. Roosevelt and William Branham's 1933 Vision=
[[Image:FDROK.jpg|right|thumb|200px|Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1933]]
William Branham claimed that in June 1933, God gave him a series of prophetic visions about future world events. The first of these allegedly concerned President Franklin D. Roosevelt and the Second World War. Branham maintained throughout his ministry that these visions were "Thus Saith The Lord" — direct divine revelation, infallible by definition.
 
That claim collapses under examination.
 
This article applies a simple, fair test: does the evidence support the conclusion that Branham received a genuine prophetic vision about FDR in 1933? We will examine the prophecy's origins, its content, its internal consistency, and its historical accuracy — and we will let the primary sources speak for themselves.
----
 
== The Biblical Standard: Why This Matters ==
Before examining the evidence, we need to establish the standard by which any prophetic claim must be judged. This is not our standard — it is God's standard, given in Deuteronomy 18:21–22:<blockquote>''"You may say in your heart, 'How will we know the word which the LORD has not spoken?' When a prophet speaks in the name of the LORD, if the thing does not come about or come true, that is the thing which the LORD has not spoken. The prophet has spoken it presumptuously; you shall not be afraid of him."''</blockquote>The test is absolute and binary. A genuine prophet of God does not have a mixed record. One false prophecy is disqualifying. Branham himself invoked this standard repeatedly, insisting his prophetic record was perfect: ''"Can anyone prove any of those visions wrong? Were they not all fulfilled?"'' ''(Laodicean Church Age, Chapter 9)''


[[Image:FDROK.jpg|right|thumb|200px|Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1933]]
We will answer that question.
----
 
== The Prophecy Appears — 25 Years Later ==
Branham claimed the FDR vision occurred in 1933. If true, this was a remarkable prediction: a sitting president named by name, the Second World War foretold before a single shot was fired in Europe.
 
One would expect such a prophecy to be mentioned immediately, documented carefully, and repeated often. Branham claimed it ''was'' written down. He referenced it as being "on paper" in at least three separate sermons.
 
Yet there is no public record of Branham mentioning the FDR prophecy in any sermon prior to '''September 27, 1958''' — a full '''25 years''' after the alleged vision.
 
During those 25 years, Branham preached extensively. He mentioned Franklin D. Roosevelt by name at least ten times. He preached about Pearl Harbour on multiple occasions. He preached about WWII repeatedly. At no point did he say: ''"I prophesied in 1933 that FDR would lead the world to war — and it came to pass."''
 
This is not an argument from silence. This is a pattern. A preacher who possessed a verified, written, fulfilled prophecy about the most consequential war in human history would have a powerful validation tool at his fingertips — and he never once used it during the war itself, the post-war years, or the early 1950s. The first mention comes only in 1958, by which time an entire generation had no way of verifying what was or was not "on paper" in 1933.
----
 
== The Content Changes Repeatedly ==
Branham stated the prophecy was written down. A written record should produce a consistent account. It did not.
 
Here is the documented evolution of the prophecy across seven years, drawn entirely from Branham's own recorded sermons:
{| class="wikitable"
!Date
!What Branham Said
|-
|September 27, 1958
|FDR "would run and make that fourth term" — Thus Saith The Lord<ref>It also said what would take place, and about Roosevelt and them things, how he would run and make that fourth term. Perfectly, just exactly the way it come to pass... that's THUS SAITH THE LORD."'' (September 27, 1958, Jeffersonville, Indiana) </ref>
|-
|November 13, 1960
|FDR "will cause the whole world to go to war... Germany never picked on us; we picked on them"<ref>''I'd like to read you a prophecy that was given...This one first.  I speak this in the Name of the Lord.  The president which now is, President Franklin D. Roosevelt... (Now remember, this is twenty-eight years ago.) will cause the whole world to go to war... Now, look what happened now. In... President Franklin D. Roosevelt took America to England's tea party. That's right. ''Germany never picked on us; we picked on them, throwed the whole world into a war, to cause a world war.'' (Condemnation by Representation, November 13, 1960) </ref>
|-
|November 25, 1960
|FDR "will cause the world to go into a world war through his administration"<ref> ''Said, "We now have a president (Dwi... Mr. Roosevelt), and this Mr. Roosevelt will cause the world to go into a world war through his--in his time of his administration, his--his--as president," ''(Conference, November 25, 1960)</ref>
|-
|December 5, 1960
|"Roosevelt would take the world to war"<ref>''How many remembers that vision here in the church? Sure. Said that how that even Kennedy would be elected in this last election. How that women would be permitted to vote. How that Roosevelt would take the world to war.'' (The Ephesian Church Age, December 5 1960) </ref>
|-
|December 8, 1960
|"I seen this President Roosevelt leading the world to a world war: predicted"<ref>''And I seen this President Roosevelt leading the world to a world war: predicted.'' (The Thyatirean Church Age, December 8, 1960) </ref>
|-
|December 11, 1960
|FDR "helped cause the world to go to war" ''(note the shift from "caused" to "helped cause")''<ref> ''But the Lord showed me a vision of the great powerful woman, in '33, 1933, it's on paper. Of how that Roosevelt would cause... He helped cause the world to go to war.'' (The Laodicean Church Age, December 11, 1960) </ref>
|-
|January 28–29, 1961
|"We'd go to a world war" — FDR's connection minimized<ref> ''I picked up an old book there that the--the Lord had gave me a vision in 1933 when I just first become a minister, going down to the Baptist Tabernacle. And He gave me a vision that morning, and I seen the first one I remember of an international affair. And I seen that President Roosevelt that was in then, and seen that we'd go to a world war.'' (Why, January 28,1961) and ''And immediately after that, Mr. Roosevelt--truly in the time of his administration here--the world went to war.''(Turning Northward, January 29, 1961) </ref>
|-
|March 12, 1961
|"President Roosevelt was going to help lead the world to a world war"<ref>''1933, one morning going to the Baptist tabernacle, I went into a trance, saw a vision. I saw President Roosevelt was going to help lead the world to a world war, told it that morning. They was going to lock me up for it. And I said, "They'll go to war with Germany."'' (Jehovah Jireh, March 12,1961) </ref>
|-
|March 19, 1961
|"This President, Franklin D. Roosevelt, he will cause all the world, help do it, send the world to war" — "Thus Saith The Lord"<ref>''I seen it, thirty--1931. Seven things happened. I got it right on paper here with me, wrote it in 1931. How that I said, "This President, Franklin D. Roosevelt, he will cause all the world, help do it, send the world to war." Hadn't come to war yet, during times of depression. I said, "Another thing..." And my mother, a square-back Democrat, if she didn't look at me hard when I said that. I said, "I don't care if there's a Republican or if he was a Socialist or whatever he is, this is THUS SAITH THE LORD."'' (Jezebel Religion, March 19,1961) </ref>
|-
|August 6, 1961
|Returns to original version: FDR "will run into the fourth term... and we will be taken to a second world war"<ref>''...said, "The President that now is (I copied this off of the old Scripture--old thing yesterday)--that the President that we now have, which was (how many remembers whose it was?) Franklin D. Roosevelt..." I said, "The President we have in now will run even in the fourth term (He's on his first then.)--will run into the fourth term, and we will be taken to a second world war." '' (The Seventieth Week of Daniel, August 6, 1961)</ref>
|}
Notice what is happening across this timeline. The prophecy begins (in 1958) with the relatively modest claim that FDR would win a fourth term. It then escalates dramatically in late 1960 to the claim that FDR directly and actively ''caused'' WWII. It then quietly retreats from that bold claim — from "caused" to "helped cause" — before eventually returning to the softer original version in August 1961.
 
After 1961, the FDR prophecy disappears entirely. When the Church Ages Book was published in 1965, the reference to Roosevelt was replaced by a prophecy about Hitler — without acknowledgment or explanation.
 
If a prophecy is "on paper," its content does not evolve. Its scope does not expand under enthusiasm and contract under scrutiny. A document either says what it says or it does not. What we see instead is a prophecy whose content tracked the rhetorical needs of its teller, not the fixed record of a divine revelation.
----
 
== The Historical Problem: What Actually Happened ==
Even granting Branham the most generous possible interpretation, the central historical claim — that FDR "picked on the Germans" and thereby started WWII — is factually inaccurate.
 
'''The facts are these:'''
 
* World War II in Europe began on September 1, 1939, when Germany invaded Poland. The United States was not involved.
* For over two years, the United States remained officially neutral, despite significant public and political debate.
* The United States entered the war on December 8, 1941 — not against Germany, but following Japan's attack on Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941.
* It was '''Germany''' that declared war on the '''United States''' on December 11, 1941 — not the other way around.
 
Branham's own version — that "Germany never picked on us; we picked on them" — directly contradicts this sequence of events. Germany declared war on America. America did not declare war on Germany in the Pacific theater; Congress responded to a Japanese attack. FDR did not "throw the whole world into a war."
 
'''What about FDR's pre-war policies?''' Some historians have examined FDR's support for Britain through Lend-Lease, his naval patrols in the Atlantic, and his economic pressure on Japan. These are legitimate areas of historical debate. But here is the critical point: even historians who argue FDR was more interventionist than neutral do not conclude that FDR ''caused'' WWII or that Germany was the innocent party "picked on" by America. Hitler's expansionist program and the invasion of Poland preceded any American policy decision. To argue otherwise is not a fringe interpretation — it is a fabrication.
 
The claim that FDR started WWII is simply not supported by mainstream historical scholarship. If Branham's prophecy required this claim to be true for its fulfillment, the prophecy failed.
----
 
== The Vanishing Prophecy: An Editorial Admission ==
Perhaps the most telling piece of evidence is what was ''not'' written.


=1960 retelling of the 1933 prophecy=
When the Church Ages Book was published in 1965, it contained this statement about the 1933 visions: ''"an Austrian by the name of Adolph Hitler would rise up as dictator over Germany, and that he would draw the world into war."'' There is '''no mention of Roosevelt''' anywhere in the book. ''(Laodicean Church Age, Chapter 9)''
'' I'd like to read you a prophecy that was given... This one first.  I speak this in the Name of the Lord.  The president which now is, President Franklin D. Roosevelt. (Now remember, this is twenty-eight years ago.) will cause the whole world to go to war. (Now, look what happened now.) In...President Franklin D. Roosevelt took America to England's tea party. That's right. Germany never picked on us; we picked on them, throwed the whole world into a war, to cause a world war.'' (Condemnation by Representation, November 13, 1960)  


This is significant for two reasons. First, it was Branham and his editor Lee Vayle who made this substitution — replacing FDR with Hitler as the war-causing figure. Second, this is the very book in which Branham challenges readers: ''"Can anyone prove any of those visions wrong?"''


=Problems with the prophecy=
'''He removed the vision that could be proven wrong, then asked if any vision could be proven wrong.'''
In the Laodicean Church Age book, William Branham says, “Now let me say this. Can anyone prove any of those visions wrong? Were they not all fulfilled?”  Over 80 years after 1933, we now have the benefit of hindsight in our ability to confirm the accuracy of these prophecies.
----


====He Ignored Pearl Harbour====
== The Date Problem: Branham Contradicts Himself ==
The USA did not lead the world into WWII, as William Branham prophecied.  In fact, the United States stayed out of the conflict until 1941 when Japan attacked Pearl Harbor.  It is not clear how William Branham omitted this fact, as he preached about Pearl Harbour a number of times, condemning the soldiers for their revelry.
There is one further detail that has been largely overlooked: Branham could not consistently identify the year his vision allegedly occurred.


William Branham must have realized his error, because when the Church Ages Book was published in 1965 it included the statement:
Throughout most of his ministry, Branham cited '''1933''' as the year of the visions. But in at least one sermon (March 19, 1961), he states: ''"I seen it, thirty--1931."'' He caught himself and moved on, but the slip is recorded. In another sermon (January 28, 1961), he says: ''"The Lord had gave me a vision in 1933 when I just first become a minister."''


:''an Austrian by the name of Adolph Hitler would rise up as dictator over Germany, and that he would draw the world into war.'' <ref> Laodicean Church Age, Chapter 9</ref>
A man who genuinely experienced a vision of this magnitude does not confuse the year it occurred. More importantly, a written document — which Branham repeatedly claimed to have — has a date on it. If the paper existed, it would resolve the question immediately. The date confusion is another indicator that the documentary foundation Branham claimed was not as solid as advertised.
----


====William Branham didn't like FDR====
== Why Message Believers Defend the Indefensible ==
On December 4, 1960 William Branham said, ''"There it is on paper as the Holy Spirit said...America with this President Roosevelt will be the rascal of all of them." And that's right; he was."''  William Branham's earlier statements about FDR disclose that he thought his 4 term leadership was a "dictatorship" (May 1954), and he condemned him for bringing in Catholic holidays (December 1954).  
When confronted with this evidence, some Message believers have appealed to fringe historical sources alleging that FDR secretly orchestrated WWII and that Roosevelt was indeed the sinister warmonger Branham described. This response deserves a direct reply — both about the sources and the logic.


====Changes in the prophecy over time====
'''On the sources:''' The primary website circulated in these arguments is operated by an organization widely identified by historians as the leading Holocaust denial organization in the world. Its purpose is to minimize Nazi crimes and rehabilitate convicted war criminals. <u>Citing this source in a theological argument about a Christian minister is not simply a logical error — it is a moral one.</u>
The prophecy was written down, so each retelling of it should have been consistent.  However, William Branham never mentions Roosevelt in connection with the 1933 prophecies until September 1958.  At first, FDR would run for four terms (Thus Saith The Lord).  By 1960, William Branham says the vision showed FDR picking on the Germans and starting WWII. Then, in December 1960 this changes so that FDR only "helped" the world go to war (with "Thus Saith The Lord"). In 1961 this changes back to the original version so that FDR runs for four terms, and then the prophecy disappears.  This is the only part in the series of 1933 visions that does not make it into the summary of the 1933 visions in the Church Ages Book.


A summary of the prophecies over time include:
'''On the substance:''' Even setting aside the source, the historical argument fails on its own terms. The claim that FDR secretly engineered WWII is rejected not only by mainstream historians, but by the documented timeline: Germany was already at war with Britain, France, and Poland before any American policy could have "caused" a world war. The war was not caused in Washington — it was launched from Berlin.
*1958: FDR would run for four terms. <ref>It also said what would take place, and about Roosevelt and them things, how he would run and make that fourth term. Perfectly, just exactly the way it come to pass... that's THUS SAITH THE LORD."'' (September 27, 1958, Jeffersonville, Indiana) </ref>
*1960: In the Name of the Lord, FDR would pick on the Germans and cause the whole world to go to war. <ref>''I'd like to read you a prophecy that was given...This one first.  I speak this in the Name of the Lord.  The president which now is, President Franklin D. Roosevelt... (Now remember, this is twenty-eight years ago.) will cause the whole world to go to war... Now, look what happened now. In... President Franklin D. Roosevelt took America to England's tea party. That's right. ''Germany never picked on us; we picked on them, throwed the whole world into a war, to cause a world war.'' (Condemnation by Representation, November 13, 1960) </ref>
*1960: FDR would cause WWII. <ref> ''Said, "We now have a president (Dwi... Mr. Roosevelt), and this Mr. Roosevelt will cause the world to go into a world war through his--in his time of his administration, his--his--as president," ''(Conference, November 25, 1960)</ref>
*1960: FDR would lead the world to war.  <ref>''How many remembers that vision here in the church? Sure. Said that how that even Kennedy would be elected in this last election. How that women would be permitted to vote. How that Roosevelt would take the world to war.'' (The Ephesian Church Age, December 5 1960) </ref>
*1960: Predicted FDR would lead the world to war. <ref>''And I seen this President Roosevelt leading the world to a world war: predicted.'' (The Thyatirean Church Age, December 8, 1960) </ref>
*1960: FDR helped cause the world to go to war. <ref> ''But the Lord showed me a vision of the great powerful woman, in '33, 1933, it's on paper. Of how that Roosevelt would cause... He helped cause the world to go to war.'' (The Laodicean Church Age, December 11, 1960) </ref>
*1961: Written in a book that FDR would be president when the world went to war. <ref> ''I picked up an old book there that the--the Lord had gave me a vision in 1933 when I just first become a minister, going down to the Baptist Tabernacle. And He gave me a vision that morning, and I seen the first one I remember of an international affair. And I seen that President Roosevelt that was in then, and seen that we'd go to a world war.'' (Why, January 28,1961) and ''And immediately after that, Mr. Roosevelt--truly in the time of his administration here--the world went to war.''(Turning Northward, January 29, 1961) </ref>
*1961: FDR would help lead the world into war with Germany.  <ref>''1933, one morning going to the Baptist tabernacle, I went into a trance, saw a vision. I saw President Roosevelt was going to help lead the world to a world war, told it that morning. They was going to lock me up for it. And I said, "They'll go to war with Germany."'' (Jehovah Jireh, March 12,1961) </ref>
*1961: Written on paper, FDR would help cause the world to go to war, "Thus Saith The Lord." <ref>''I seen it, thirty--1931. Seven things happened. I got it right on paper here with me, wrote it in 1931. How that I said, "This President, Franklin D. Roosevelt, he will cause all the world, help do it, send the world to war." Hadn't come to war yet, during times of depression. I said, "Another thing..." And my mother, a square-back Democrat, if she didn't look at me hard when I said that. I said, "I don't care if there's a Republican or if he was a Socialist or whatever he is, this is THUS SAITH THE LORD."'' (Jezebel Religion, March 19,1961) </ref>
*1961: FDR would be President in four terms, and the world would go to war. <ref>''...said, "The President that now is (I copied this off of the old Scripture--old thing yesterday)--that the President that we now have, which was (how many remembers whose it was?) Franklin D. Roosevelt..." I said, "The President we have in now will run even in the fourth term (He's on his first then.)--will run into the fourth term, and we will be taken to a second world war." '' (The Seventieth Week of Daniel, August 6, 1961)</ref>


=The explanation for the failed vision=
'''On the psychology:''' It is understandable that people who have built their lives, families, and identities around Branham's prophetic authority experience deep resistance when confronted with evidence of a failed prophecy. The impulse to find ''any'' explanation that preserves the belief system is human and predictable. But the biblical standard does not include an escape clause for "the prophet was right if you look at it from this angle." The standard is fulfillment — and fulfillment must be measured against verified history, not against the most favorable possible fringe interpretation.
We have received several comments that refer to secret Polish documents that purport to prove that President Roosevelt was secretly campaigning to incite war in Europe.  As proof, they point to a website that contains an article detailing the sordid details of Roosevelt's plot. The problem is that the website that they refer to is well known as an antisemitic pseudo-scholarly body with links to neo-Nazi organizations.  Its primary purpose is to disseminate views denying key facts of Nazism. It has been described as the "world's leading Holocaust denial organization." This is evident by an article on the front page of the website in support of Rudolph Hess, a convicted war criminal.
----


The fact is that this information is not only completely unproven, but also totally at odds with the work of reputable historical scholars.
== Conclusion: A Failed Prophecy by Any Standard ==
The FDR prophecy fails at every level of scrutiny:


Why do we receive comments like this?  The reason is that people who believe that William Branham was a prophet become frustrated when confronted with a false statement by their beloved prophet.  This is known as [[Cognitive Dissonance|cognitive dissonance]], and often results in Message Believers grasping at straws, or conspiracy theories, in order to keep the status quo of their lives.  It is disturbing to think you are "a special elect" one minute, only to realize that you are deceived.  As a result, it is mentally and emotionally easier to cling to anything that would support William Branham as a true prophet.
* '''Timing:''' Not mentioned publicly for 25 years, despite countless opportunities
* '''Consistency:''' The content changed dramatically across multiple retellings
* '''Documentation:''' A supposedly written record produced wildly inconsistent accounts
* '''Historical accuracy:''' The central claim — that FDR caused WWII — is contradicted by established historical fact
* '''Institutional acknowledgment:''' The prophecy was quietly removed from the Church Ages Book and replaced with a more defensible claim about Hitler
* '''Internal contradiction:''' Branham himself confused the year of the vision in his own sermons


='''References'''=
God's standard in Deuteronomy 18 is not complex: ''"If the thing does not come about or come true, that is the thing which the LORD has not spoken."''
<div class="references-small" style="-moz-column-count:2; column-count:2;">
<references/>
</div>


{{7 Visions}}
The thing did not come about as Branham described. The Lord did not speak this prophecy.
----''For further examination of the 1933 visions and William Branham's prophetic claims, see [[Under The Halo|Under the Halo: Examining the Legacy of William Branham]] and the full analysis of [[An Analysis of William Branham's Visions and Prophecies|Branham's Visions and Prophecies]].''
----{{Bottom of Page}}
[[index.php?title=Category:Prophecies and Visions of William Branham]]
[[index.php?title=Category:1933 Visions]]
Retrieved from "https://en.believethesign.com/index.php/Franklin_D._Roosevelt"